Roofing

Sizing a Dumpster for a Roof Tear-Off

Roofing is where sizing goes wrong most often, and here it is almost always the same two things: a second layer, or soft decking under it.

The one number that matters: squares

Roofers measure in squares. One square is 100 square feet of roof surface. A typical house across the Quad Cities runs somewhere between 18 and 30 squares — the older river-city houses at the lower end, the newer suburban builds higher.

If you do not know your square count, your roofer does, and it is the first thing to ask.

What a square of roofing weighs

The overwhelming majority of residential roofs here are composition shingle, which keeps the arithmetic simple — until you find two layers.

Composition sizing table

Add a size if the decking is coming off too, and step down to a 10 yard with swaps for slate.

The second layer problem

The most common sizing mistake on roofing work anywhere, and common here because of when this housing was built and re-roofed.

A great many houses across the Quad Cities have had a second layer of composition laid directly over the original rather than a full tear-off. It was normal, permitted practice for decades. It also roughly doubles the tear-off weight.

How to check before you book:

• Look at the rake edge from the ground. A double layer usually shows as a noticeably thicker band at the roof edge.
• Look at the flashing and drip edge. Two layers often sit proud of them.
• Ask your roofer to confirm at inspection. They will know within a minute of getting up there.

If it turns up on the day, call us. A swap mid-job is far cheaper than an overloaded container that cannot legally be hauled, and the crew keeps working while the truck is on its way.

Ice dams and what they do underneath

The local factor, and the reason roofs here often need more than shingles replacing.

Quad Cities winters produce real ice damming at the eaves — snow melts higher up the roof where the attic is warmer, runs down, and refreezes at the cold overhang. Water then backs up under the shingles rather than running off.

What that means when the roof comes off:

• The eaves are where the damage concentrates. Expect soft decking in the first few feet above the wall line.
• Fascia and soffit often need work at the same time, and that is extra material in the container.
• Repeated freeze-thaw degrades shingles and sealants faster than a milder climate would, so replacement cycles here are shorter than the shingle warranty suggests.
• A second layer makes it worse — trapped moisture between layers has nowhere to go.
• Attic ventilation is usually the underlying cause, and if it is not fixed the new roof will do the same thing.

If your roof has had ice dams, assume decking replacement is likely rather than possible, and size accordingly.

Decking is the hidden variable

You do not know the condition of the decking until the shingles are off, and it is the single most common reason a roofing container runs over.

Plywood and OSB are heavy — roughly 40 to 60 pounds a sheet. A roof needing widespread decking replacement can add a ton or more that nobody budgeted for, on top of the shingles.

On older houses here there is a second possibility: plank decking rather than sheet. Dimensional boards laid across the rafters were standard before plywood and are heavier again per square foot — and the older Moline and Rock Island neighborhoods have plenty of housing that age.

Two responses, both fine:

• Size up one when you book if the roof is old, has had ice dams, or carries a second layer.
• Accept you may need a swap and factor it in.

What does not work is overfilling. A container loaded above the rail cannot legally be hauled, and the truck will leave without it — which costs a day as well as a return trip.

Storm and insurance work

A meaningful share of roofing work here is storm-driven — wind, hail and the aftermath of a hard freeze.

• Photograph everything before anything moves. The adjuster will want it, and once the shingles are in a container they are gone.
• Do not dispose of damaged material until the claim is settled unless your adjuster has confirmed you can.
• Check whether your policy covers debris removal — it is often a separate line.
• Book early after a major event. Every roofer and every hauler in the Quad Cities is busy the same fortnight and containers genuinely run out.
• Separate fencing, gutters and siding if the same storm took those down — different streams and different weights.
• Emergency tarping is different from clearing up. Do it, and keep the receipts.

Placement, canopy and the nail problem

Roofing containers need to sit close to the house, and here there are three recurring constraints.

Overhead branches. Twenty-two feet of clear height to raise the bed, and the mature canopy in the older neighborhoods is genuinely low. On a job with a mid-course swap that has to work twice.

Driveway width. In the older Rock Island and Moline streets and the narrow river villages, a 15 yard with a swap is often the workable shape where a 20 simply will not place.

Winter. Snow banks narrow the drive, and an open container through a snowfall gains real weight — a tear-off is exactly the material that soaks. Ask for a cover if the job runs across several days.

Everywhere: boards go under the rails as standard, and a tear-off sheds an enormous quantity of nails. A magnet sweep of the drive and the street at the end is twenty minutes well spent, and it is the single most common complaint homeowners have about roofing work.